From Bentham’s theory to “pseudopanopticon”: A model of psycho-historical analysis from the “failure” of the Spanish prisons reform in the 19th Century to the “digital panopticon” of the 21st Century

Main Article Content

Francisco Pérez Fernández

Abstract

Michel Foucault made the Benthamian panoptism cornerstone of his criticism of the modern technology of punishment allegedly "humanitarian" and "rehabilitator" as defended by the Enlightenment, whose maximum expression was manifested as "constant reform of prisons", is no less true that the panoptic model of Jeremy Bentham, which for decades was seen as the epitome of a modern correctional system, positive, efficient, economically productive, psychologically accurate and morally healthy, actually had a more theoretical than real impact on Western prison systems . The theory of the panopticon ran into all sorts of economic and technical difficulties that made it a sort of imaginative psychosocial experiment without the possibility of real implantation. Thus, the very concept of "panopticon" ended up going from the noun to the adjective, and all the literature built around the "eye that sees everything" was revealed as a mere intellectual fiction. This work, of psicohistorical research, tries to outline from its introduction in Spain of that technological project that reformed the presidios that was the panoptist ideology, and how its failure materialized, despite the enthusiasm of its defenders. However, and paradoxically, far from implying this failure a renunciation of the model, it served as an incentive to redirect it towards the reformulation of a genuine "prison theory" - and "the prisoner" - that found articulation in a whole philosophy of the penitentiary reform, the control of the spaces and the treatment of the prisoner that he framed in the juridical changes and in the architectural projects, as well as the very ideal of "re-education”.

Article Details

Section

Papers

How to Cite

From Bentham’s theory to “pseudopanopticon”: A model of psycho-historical analysis from the “failure” of the Spanish prisons reform in the 19th Century to the “digital panopticon” of the 21st Century. (2024). Edupsykhé. Revista De Psicología Y Educación, 21(1), 58-74. https://doi.org/10.57087/edupsykhe.v21i1.4771